Hanging With Free Cooper Union

Like the six floors below it, the seventh floor of the Cooper Union’s Foundation Building has been transformed into an art gallery—Tuesday night was the first night of the annual Cooper Union End of Year Show. The seventh floor is not listed on any official materials, however, because for the past three weeks it has been occupied by students protesting the proposal that the school begin charging undergraduate tuition, a violation, they feel of the Cooper Union’s stated mission: “The College admits undergraduates solely on merit and awards full scholarships to all enrolled students.”

The first six floors of the Foundation Building feel like a museum—antiseptic white, orderly and clean. The floors, walls, and ceiling of the seventh floor have been painted black, and the walls are crowded with art from students, alumni, faculty, and the community at large that embodies Peter Cooper’s imperative, “Education should be as free as air and water.”

A long black banner hangs outside the Cooper Union President Jamshed Bharucha’s office. It reads, in capital red letters: “Cooper, what is best in life? To crush your trustees, to see them driven before you, and to hear the lamentations of their accountants.”

As committed as they are to their cause, a sense of playfulness permeates everything about the Free Cooper Union movement. On a table there is a pile of letters on official Cooper Union letterhead—indeed, Jamshed Bharucha’s personal letterhead. “At this time, after much personal deliberation I cannot ignore these students and their growing concerns,” it reads. “It is with much gratitude and respect that I announce my resignation effective immediately.”

Two paragraphs later, it continues, “With great power comes great responsibility,” which is from Spiderman and probably the last defense against someone not understanding that this is a joke.

Two walls of Jamshed Bharucha’s corner office are taken up by floor-to-ceiling windows, looking out over Cooper Square and towards the East River. With a pile of sleeping bags jammed in the corner and books, papers, and board games strewn across the conference table it feels a little bit like a treehouse. When it rains, the rainwater streams down a dozen enormous windows and Saar Shemesh told me that she imagines the office is a submarine. Sometimes when the sun rises the new building at 41 Cooper Square looks like it is on fire.

“We are in control here, and they [the Board of Trustees] don’t know what to do about it,” said Shemesh. They do not expect to be forcibly removed—although rumors abound that ‘something’ is going to happen on Friday—and the administration has rescinded all threats of suspension or other internal punishment. And yet, Shemesh continued, “I don’t think there’s anything we could do to get them to talk to us and take what we’re saying seriously.”

The occupation so far would not have been possible without help from past graduates: “We wouldn’t be able to eat without the alumni,” said rising sophomore Andi Overton. Bharucha’s office is also brightened by flowers sent by alumni.

All of this serves as a weighty counterpoint to Chairman of the Board of Trustees Mark Epstein’s complaint during a Democracy Now! debate that part of the school’s difficulty in raising revenue has been a lack of financial support from alumni (“Traditionally, only 20 percent of our alumni, who have gotten 100 percent scholarships, give back to the school on a regular basis… And most—some of the loudest voices of our alumni against this new change in policy… do not appear on donor lists. So, I question their commitment to the school other than verbal.”) Student activist Victoria Sobel countered that there is frustration among many alumni at their inability to give in a way that would go directly towards aiding tuition costs: “I have seen many alumni, that would be more than willing to give, if the money could be explicitly saved for covering the tuition costs of students.”

Equally important to the Free Cooper Union movement are the incoming students, the first class to be charged tuition under the current plan—indeed, they and all future students are whom the occupiers are fighting for (all current students are guaranteed four years of free tuition). The board used the class as a bargaining chip when, in February, the Dean of Admissions sent an email to all early decision applicants deferring their admission until the art department faculty approved the tuition hike option.

The activists of Free Cooper Union plan on holding a series of “Disorientation” sessions in late August and early September for new students, to educate them on the history of the movement, its mission, and the facts on the ground—or the seventh floor, as it were. (The occupiers certainly plan to stick around at least that long, expecting the arrival of a fridge sometime in the next few days.) These sessions are intended to show that there is no barrier to entry to Free Cooper Union. “It’s not a club,” said Shemesh. “It’s something, hypothetically, for everyone.”

For now, current Cooper Union students have done their best to reach out to incoming first years, hosting Skype sessions for confused high schoolers to ask questions of their future peers. “One asked, ‘Do you really think you can win?'” recalled Shemesh. “Of course we do! Why would we be here if we didn’t?”


Brendan O’Connor lives in New York. Photo via @cersonsky


6 Comments / Post A Comment

Manuel delCuevo (#4,062)

RE: “with great power….”
Ummm, that’s actually Voltaire.

Brunhilde (#78)

@Manuel delCuevo And doesn’t Peter Parker’s Uncle Ben say it before Spidey co-opts it? This is some third-hand ripped off content!

dss5 (#4,064)

Look, I love what these guys are doing, and yes it’s horrible that poor financial decisions are being paid for on the backs of students and at the cost of an awesome tradition.

THAT SAID, if more alumni were as willing to donate money to the university as they are to donate flowers and sushi to the occupiers, maybe the Union’s financial situation wouldn’t be as dire as it is.

@dss5 Hi, I’m a student who’s occupying. Thanks!

One of our main reasons for being here is to demand greater financial transparency from Cooper’s administration. We’ve heard over and over from alumni that when they donate to Cooper Union’s current administration they have *no idea* where the money is going. When alumni buy us dinner they know *exactly* where the money is going, even if supporting the occupation is a somewhat more circuitous way of supporting Cooper.

If we achieve our goals, nobody will have to fear that they’re just throwing money into a black hole of bureaucratic bloat and feeding the specious “rising costs of higher education”.

@dss5 From what I have read, 41 Cooper Square seems to have been a Bad Financial Decision. While the Board of Trustees stated that:

“It is also important to state that 41 Cooper Square was not the cause of the current financial dilemma. Its construction relieved Cooper Union of the costs that would have had to be incurred to renovate the old engineering building and the Hewitt Building to make them acceptable sites for a 21st-century education and meet accreditation standards,” (source: http://nplusonemag.com/save-cooper-union)

As a rejoinder to that statement, no one outside of the (mostly) boy’s club of the trustees knows 100% of the financial data. And this is why I assume the occupiers are demanding some sort of transparency from these not so trustworthy trustees.

Good luck, Occupiers! You’ve got the support of this uptown university graduate student.

chic noir (#713)

One of our main reasons for being here is to demand greater financial transparency from Cooper’s administration

An admirable goal.

Comments are closed!