Etsy, Regretsy, Protesty

Etsy is a marketplace for artists to sell their crafts and build a little business for themselves, but what happens when those small businesses become big businesses? TIME takes a look (subscription only) at the “handmade wars” occurring on Etsy—the conflict being that there are people who believe that Etsy should be a place to foster small-time artisans, not those who have become successful enough to hire a team of workers to churn out products and make hundreds of thousands of dollars (if not millions) a year. Mariana Schechter, a 31-year-old furniture designer who uses reclaimed wood, was was run off of Etsy once other Etsy members discovered she was outsourcing some of her work and had a team of four carpenters who helped her assemble her furniture:

Within days, angry Etsy members banded together on a website called Protesty to plan a boycott of the site. Six hundred sellers set up a petition decrying Etsy’s support of mass producers, and Schechter says she was ambushed with hate e-mails and phone calls criticizing her business. Her husband, an attorney, issued a cease-and-desist notice to an angry Etsy follower. It was swiftly posted on Regretsy.

Dickerson, Etsy’s CEO, waded in to announce his support for Schechter. In a statement posted on Etsy, he condemned the “mob mentality” of her critics and framed the situation as an oversight rather than deceit. “Ecologica Malibu is a collective shop, run on Etsy by Mariana with help from a local staff,” an Etsy administrator wrote on the site. “In keeping with Etsy’s rules, that collective should have been disclosed within the shop; this is now corrected.” That only stiffened the dissidents’ resolve: two weeks later, 4,000 sellers agreed to black out their shops for 24 hours in protest of Schechter’s featured shop.

Within weeks, Schechter closed her Etsy shop. Fearing for her safety, she moved her brick-and-mortar store to a different location in Malibu.

I understand why a community of small-time artists would like to stay small and artisanal rather than have mass-producers hanging around the site to steal their thunder, but as a buyer, I would be happy to hear that a once unknown craftsperson whose products I’ve bought and liked found enough success to expand and make more money. One couple profiled in the story has grown from selling a few thousand dollars worth of screen printed items to annual sales of $500,000 on Etsy.

Etsy is also backed by venture capitalists who have invested in Facebook and Twitter, which means the site has already been invaded by the big guys. One day every household in America will own a some chops, and then what?

Photo: maureen lunn


5 Comments / Post A Comment

BillfoldMonkey (#1,754)

The problem here is not that this particular Etsy user was small and got big. It’s that she was reselling imported manufactured crap, which goes against all of Etsy’s stated policies. This might be illuminating: This problem is rampant on Etsy and Etsy does nothing about it because they profit directly from it.

ghechr (#596)

From my understanding, Ecologica Malibu was not simply “outsourcing some of her work.” She was reselling furniture that was produced on a massive scale, the likes of which could easily be found on other sites such as Not handmade and I doubt she even had any hand in designing the furniture itself.

But, my problem with Etsy is that it pretends to be a marketplace for handmade goods when, in fact, just about anyone can put up a storefront.

Penelope Pine (#2,808)

If you’re making that kind of profit and moving that many units, you can invest in a developer and an actual online storefront. Etsy is great for buying vintage clothing, but little else. I don’t want your janky hand-crocheted bikini top or crappy “art” kthxbye.

squishycat (#3,000)

@Penelope Pine It’s a good storefront for small-time crafters who make soaps and yarn (or dye yarn they haven’t personally spun), and there are a few really excellent jewelry-makers (and some who are just fun – I purchased a very simple necklace – silk cord, D20 encased in a spiral cage as pendant – from a seller there, and was able to choose the color of the cord and the die, for less money than ThinkGeek charges for an identical item, without the choice).

Comments are closed!