Reader Mail: Company Matches and Roth IRAs

A reader asks:

I have a somewhat specific and possibly stupid question: I found your posts on 401(k)s and IRAs really helpful, and while you gave great advice about traditional IRA vs. Roth, I’m not sure how to choose between 401(k) and Roth IRA? My company matches up to three percent in my 401(k), so hell yeah free money, that’s what I’m currently enrolled in, but should I roll it over into a Roth IRA? You gave pretty compelling evidence in your IRA post about how Roths are superior to pre-tax IRAs, but what about the whole matching issue?

We don’t have a formal advice column yet, but we’re more than happy to take your questions. I’m not a “financial advisor” so I’m not going to tell you how to invest your money, that said, this question is an easy one!

This is a thing that I have done, and what most smart money people recommend: If you are lucky enough to work at a company that provides a 401(k) plan and a company match, contribute just enough money to get the full match, because yes, free money! Once you get that done, open a Roth IRA and contribute the maximum for the year, which is $5,000 if you’re younger than 50. And then if you’re this amazing person who still has more money to put away for retirement, go back to contributing to your 401(k) until you max that out. Most young people won’t get to this last part where you max out the 401(k) because the max is $17,000, and most people aren’t saving $17,000 a year. If you are, whoa, you’re amazing and will be a very rich old, and all the other olds will be jealous of you.

We’re not here to just to answer these “traditional” questions about money (but we will if that’s what you want!). Want advice on what to do when your friend owes you money, but you don’t know how to bring it up because you feel awkward about it? Or what to do when the guy or girl you’re dating practically lives at your place but isn’t paying rent? We love those questions. Send us an email!


Photo Credit: Flickr/Solo with others



Show Comments

From Our Partners